-
Why do people sue?
Money, Prevalence of lawyers, it is now more socially acceptable, increased consumerism, more active population, which leads to more injuries
-
What can be done to decrease lawsuits?
- 1.educate
- 2.change attitudes
- 3.change systems
- 4.cap monetary rewards
- 5.Have plaintiff pick up court costs of both parties if they lose the case.
-
Definition of Law
A system of principles that tells us how to behave
-
Sources of Law
- 1. case law (common law)
- 2. Constitutions and statutes (also called statuary or code law)
- 3. Administrative Law
- 4. executive branch
-
Stare Decisis (stary-deci-sis)
A decision has been made
-
Another name for case law
common law
-
Another name for Constitutions and statutes
statuary or code law
-
Administrative Law
laws, rules and regulations developed, adopted, and enforced by government unions
-
Executive branch
executive orders
-
constitutions and statutes, administrative law, and executive branch (orders) are also called?
written law
-
What are the two main types of law?
written and common law
-
Three branches of government?
- 1.Legislative
- 2.Executive
- 3.Judicial
-
Legislative does what?
makes laws
-
Executive branch does what?
Enforces the law
-
The Judicial branch does what?
interprets law
-
Sovereign immunity is also called what?
governmental immunity
-
Sovereign immunity means?
“can’t sue the government” without consent
-
Federal Tort Claims Act (1946) did what?
gave public the right to sue the government
-
What are the two types of law?
Criminal and Civil
-
Criminal Law
- a.Offenses against society
- b.State acts on behalf of the people
- c.Decisions must be unanimous “beyond reasonable doubt”
-
Civil Law
- a.Rules that govern non-criminal affairs
- b.Injured party takes initiative
- c.Decisions are majority rule based on the “preponderance of the evidence”
-
Damages (or remedies) that can be sought in a civil suit
- ·General or compensatory – pain, suffering, or humiliation
- ·Special – financial loss (medical)
- ·Punitive or exemplary – malice or viciousness
- ·Normal – injury suffered is considered slight
- but the responsibility of the party must be recognized
- ·Attorney fees (some cases, the only thing they will reward)
-
What is government in our field?
- ·Public college athletic department
- ·Public recreation department
-
Methods of collecting facts?
Interrogatories and Depositions
-
Interrogatories
written questions are sent to the opposite side and must be answered under oath.
-
Depositions
verbal statements recorded under oath.
-
When a case goes to jury (or judge) decision involves what?
- · What happened based on the evidence that is presented
- ·Decide whether the plaintiff was damaged by the defendant(s) act.
- ·Decide the monetary reward
- · Judge, Decides whether a legal duty was owed and other questions of law and applies rules and procedures
-
What is an appellate court?
often a panel of three or more judges. (usually an odd number)
-
Appellate court looks at..
procedural process of the case and misapplication of law
-
If appeal is accepted (sustained): Actions of the Appellate court are?
- 1.affirm
- 2.reverse
- 3.Remand
- 4.Can adjust monetary rewards
- 5.Dismiss (with prejudice)
-
Affirm
agrees with lower court
-
Reverse
reverse the decision of the lower court
-
remand
send back to lower court for retrial.
-
If appeal is denied, what else can happen?
It can be taken to a higher court (except when dismissed with prejudice)
-
Statute of limitations
Amount of time an individual has to file a lawsuit after an incident occurred
-
If you are suing a governmental agency you have...?
180 days (6 months) to file
-
Under Statute of limitations how long does an adult have to file?
2-3 years
-
Under Statute of limitations how long does a minor have to file?
can be tolling. Until they are 18 and then MAYBE 2-3 years after
-
most common reasons of lawsuits in sport are?
- 1.safety rules – failure to create or follow
- 2.supervision – inadequate or non-existent
- 3.equipment – non-existent, doesn’t fit or is improperly maintained
- 4.Medical Care – Not available or improperly administered
- 5.Unsafe, improper, or poorly designed facilities
-
Legal Liability
A reasonability between two parties which is recognized by the courts.
-
Tort
A civil wrong; non-criminal
-
3 functions of tort law (why it exists)
- 1.used to compensate a person sustaining injuries or damages
- 2.places the compensation on those who ought to bear it
- 3.acts as a deterrent
-
unintentional torts
negligence
-
negligence
unintentional failure to person one’s duty up the standards expected of a prudent professional under similar circumstances
-
Ways to transfer Risk
- 1.Avoid games and events (last thing a sport manager wants to do)
- 2.Reduce
- 3.Transfer
- 4.Retain
-
Risk Management
Prevention and reduction of accidents through careful design, implementation, and enforcement of a series of planned steps.
-
Who is responsible for risk management?
Everyone, but one person in charge is needed.
-
How to create a risk management plan?
- 1. Get approval to develop the plan
- 2.Make sure those above you will support use and implementation ( May cost extra $$$, but may save in the long run in decreased lawsuits, medical payments, and possible insurance fees)
- 3.Document the plan and everything related like File copies with supervisor(s) and maintain accurate maintenance and inspection records and use accident records to predict foresee ability.
-
insurance protection
which provides for the compensation to employees who suffer injury in the course of their employment. (different in every state) – This is transferring risk!
-
unintentional tort
injures an individual in person, property, or reputation.
-
Four elements of negligence
- 1.Duty – obligatory conduct owed
- 2.Breach of duty – failure to provide a standard of care which a reasonable prudent person would provide under similar circumstances
- 3.Injury occurred
- 4.Proximate cause – did the breach cause the injury
-
Three types of breach
- Act of commission
- Act of omission
- Malfeasance
-
Act of commission
responding incorrectly; also called misfeasance (mistreating an injury)
-
Act of omission
failure to do something or respond to a legal duty. Also called nonfeasance
-
Malfeasance
doing something not allowed to do so by law (malpractice)
-
Three degrees of negligence
- Ordinary
- Gross
- Willful, wanton, or reckless
-
Ordinary
failure to exercise such care as the great majority would ordinarily exercise under the same or similar circumstance. (also called simple or general)
-
gross
very great negligence
-
Willful, wanton, or reckless
conduct is so “gross” as to have something of a criminal character or be deemed equivalent to an evil intent. (hazing, bulling)
-
Three standards of care
- Reasonable person
- Special relationships
- Professional standard
-
Reasonable person
applies to society in general
-
Special relationships
people and agencies (school, and parents, sport orgs) –duty to render essential emergency medical assistance.
-
professional standard
a duty to perform at the level expected of a person with the training, knowledge, and skill of a member of the profession
-
Two types of duty
Ministerial and Discretionary
-
Ministerial
clearly defined; a little room for interpretation. A person performs in a prescribed manner without regard to or the exercise of his/her own judgment.
-
Discretionary
performs on the basis of judgment or choice
-
Rule of seven
This is NOT a defense. This is a way of explaining how much risk can be assumed
- oUnder age 7 – assumes no risk
- oAge 7-13 – can assume some risk
- oAges 14-21 – can assume some (most) risk, but not all
- oAdults – assume most risk but not in situations when risk is not understood. (most being 99%)
-
Act of God
(act of nature, to get away fromreligious fight) – caused by nature (struck by lightning)
-
Respondeat (latin) Superior
can be used whenan employee (defendant) is acting on behalf of the employer and a tort isincurred; the employer must accept the responsibility. ( you are taking ids at the gym and your bosssays let him in, and they get hurt)
-
Defenses of negligence
- Act of God
- Respondeat (latin) Superior
- Waivers/releases
- Sovereign immunity/other immunity statutes
- Recreational land use statutes
- Failure of proof or no negligence
- Statute of limitations
- Notice of claim
- Any contract, facility lease
- Equipment rental agreements
- Any applicable law – (ie, Volunteer Protection
- Act)
-
Notice of Claim
when suing some governmental bodies, plaintiff must first file a notice of claim. If they don’t, case can be thrown out until this is done.
-
Failure of proof or no negligence
when suing some governmental bodies, plaintiff must first file a notice of claim. If they don’t, case can be thrown out until this is done.
-
Two types (maybe 3) of Supervision
- General
- Specific
- transitional
-
General Supervision
- Adequate staffing
- Responding to emergencies
- Checking facility – maintain safe environment
- Warning patrons of hazards
- Controlling patron behavior
-
Specific supervision – Direct contact is needed when:
- Clients involved do not appreciate the risks of the activity (life guard, people don’t understand risk of swimming).
- Clients cannot access their own physical or skill level
- Clients cannot understand and follow safety rules and procedures
-
Workman's Compensation
- The employee bears the cost of insurance in return for some immunity from lawsuits by employees for negligence.
- The worker receives compensation for lost income and medical expenses (1/2-2/3 of salary)
- Workers must file a claim to receive money; show injury was on the job.
- Cannot receive money for pain and suffering
- If the employee files a lawsuit, they generally forfeit right to money from workman’s comp.
- Can cover volunteers – prevent lawsuits
-
Origin of duty
- Voluntary assumption of interpersonal relationships. (No duty owed unless a relationship is created and Good Samaritan laws and Worsening the condition)
- Any form of written law, business invitation, or judicial decision – if from a law – statutory
- Inherent in the situation
-
Ultra vires act
acting beyond the scope of duty
-
Defenses of negligence
- Primary assumption of risk
- Secondary assumption of risk
- comparative negligence
-
Primary assumption of risk
plaintiff usually cannot recover for an injury if they: Had knowledge of dangerous elements , Understood the nature and extent of danger, and Subjected oneself to the danger
-
Secondary assumption of risk (also known as contributory negligence)
- Did something to contribute to their injury (book decided to play on a poor field ie, rain, field is wet)
- Some states do not separate primary and secondary
-
How to determine what kind of supervision is neeeded?
- Physical layout of facility
- Facility condition (environment and floors)
- Client: Age and maturity, physical condition, and skill level
- Differences in activity – specific risks
-
Supervision is a ________.
Duty
-
Four classifications of comparative negligence
- pure comparative rule
- 50% rule
- 49% rule
- slight gross
-
pure comparative rule
uses absolute percentages when trying to figure out who contributed how much to an injury
-
50% rule
an equally negligent plaintiff is permitted to recover. (pay 50% of what the court awards
-
49% rule
an equally negligent plaintiff doesn’t get anything.
-
Slight gross
whatever the court decides. “was your negligence slightly gross” there is no clear cut amount.
-
Satisfaction of legal duty
requires adherence to the specific standard of care applicable based on the situation
|
|