-
Bowen - Theory of Change
Change occurs by understanding multigenerational dynamics and differentiation.
-
Bowen - Therapist’s Role
- ● Coach/educator
- ● Supervisor
- ● Investigator
- ● Neutral
-
Bowen - Treatment Goals
- ● Reduce anxiety and emotional turmoil in family system
- ● Self-differentiation within the context of family
- ● Decrease emotional fusion
- ● Improve communication skills
- ● Decrease recurrence of dysfunctional patterns
- ● Reduce emotional reactivity
- ● Facilitate de-triangulation
-
Bowen - Key Concepts
- Triangles
- Differentiation of Self
- Nuclear Family Emotional System
- Family Projection Process
- Multigenerational Transmission Process
- Emotional Cutoff
- Genogram
-
Triangles
- A triangle is a three-person relationship system. It is considered the building
- block or “molecule” of larger emotional systems because a triangle is the smallest stable
- relationship system.
-
Differentiation of Self
- Families and other social groups tremendously affect how people
- think, feel, and act, but individuals vary in their susceptibility to a “group think” and
- groups vary in the amount of pressure they exert for conformity. These differences
- between individuals and between groups reflect differences in people’s levels of
- differentiation of self.
-
Nuclear Family Emotional System
- The concept of the nuclear family emotional system
- describes four basic relationship patterns that govern where problems develop in a
- family. People’s attitudes and beliefs about relationships play a role in the patterns, but
- the forces primarily driving them are part of the emotional system.
-
Family Projection Process
- The family projection process describes the primary way
- parents transmit their emotional problems to a child. The projection process can impair
- the functioning of one or more children and increase their vulnerability to clinical
- symptoms.
-
Multigenerational Transmission Process
- The concept of the multigenerational
- transmission process describes how small differences in the levels of differentiation between parents and their offspring lead over many generations to marked differences in
- differentiation among the members of a multigenerational family.
-
Emotional Cutoff
- The concept of emotional cutoff describes people managing their
- unresolved emotional issues with parents, siblings, and other family members by
- reducing or totally cutting off emotional contact with them.
-
Genogram
- Extensive study of family’s history. Acts both as an assessment and
- treatment tool.
-
Bowen - Interventions
- ● Reduce emotional reactivity by having family members talk to the therapist.
- ● Reframing
- ● Genogram
- ● De-triangulation
- ● Increasing Differentiation
- ● Teaching “I” Statements
- ● Opening Cutoff Relationships
- ● Interacts with Family
- ● Models
- ● Bibliotherapy
-
Reframing
The presenting problem as a multigenerational problem that is caused by factors beyond the individual.
-
Bibliotherapy
Assigning reading material.
-
Models
Demonstrates new ways to interact and communicate.
-
Interacts with Family
Interrupts arguments – open conflict is prohibited as it raises anxiety.
-
Teaching “I” Statements
Increases differentiation.
-
Opening Cutoff Relationships
- Encouraging and supporting clients to re-engage with
- estranged family members.
-
Genogram
Create a multigenerational map of family emotional system.
-
De-triangulation
- Therapist becomes part of a "healthy triangle" where the therapist
- teaches the couple to manage their own anxiety, distance, and closeness in healthy
- ways.
-
Increasing Differentiation
By forming supportive relationship with family members to explore the origins and effects of their families beliefs and behaviors.
-
Bowen - Beginning Phase
- Create a family diagram of multigenerational emotional connections; assess
- individuals’ levels of differentiation and triangulation; identify dysfunctional patterns that have
- been passed along through the generations.
-
Bowen - Early/Middle Phase
- Teach and model differentiation through communication skill building;
- de-triangulation; encourage reunification from cutoff family members; teach the family how to
- take responsibility for their feelings and thoughts.
-
Bowen - End Phase
Review new skills and knowledge gained in therapy.
-
General Systems - Theory of Change
- ● Change occurs by helping the system view the problem in the context of the family,
- rather than view an individual as the problem.
- ● The family system becomes the focal point of therapeutic interventions.
-
General Systems - Role of the Therapist
- ● The therapist helps the family explore:
- ○ Belief systems and family values
- ○ Rules and roles that are present in the family
- ○ The family hierarchy
- ○ Expectations
- ○ Defense mechanisms and their purpose
-
General Systems - Main Concepts
- Homeostasis
- Feedback Loops
- Negative Feedback (attenuating)
- Positive Feedback (amplifying)
- Calibration
- Wholeness
- Equifinality
- Equipotentiality
- First Order Change
- Second Order Change
- Nonsummativity
- Boundaries
-
Homeostasis
- Systems tend to resist change and deal with issues by keeping things the
- same rather than dealing with problems. It is maintained through negative feedback
- loops.
-
Feedback Loops
- Circular in nature, information pathways that help the system balance
- and correct itself. These can be positive or negative.
-
Negative Feedback (attenuating)
- Behavioral reactions used by families that
- correct departures from the system’s normal state and return the system to its
- previous state of homeostasis. Corrects against change.
-
Positive Feedback (amplifying)
- Behavioral reactions that amplify departures
- from the system's normal state, which initially destabilizes the system and
- eventually changes the family’s homeostasis. Allows system to adapt to change.
-
Calibration
The normal operational system of the family.
-
Wholeness
- This is the notion that the whole system, all of the units combined, is greater
- than the sum of its parts. The interactions between the individuals have an effect on the
- system as a whole.
-
Equifinality
- The same results can be accomplished by different family systems.
- ○ Example: A man experienced the death of his mother when he was a young child,
- whereas a woman experienced the divorce of her parents when she was an
- infant. As adults, both of these individuals experienced Major Depression despite
- having different early experiences.
-
Equipotentiality
- On the other hand, the same experience in a family system can end up
- with various results later in life.
- ○ Example: Two siblings go through the same experience of verbal abuse when
- they were young. Later in life, one sibling struggles with relationships, whereas the other sibling struggles with depression. Therefore, despite the same
- experience early on, different results occurred.
-
First Order Change
- Changes that occur in the family that are more surface level and
- temporary. They do not affect the rules or organization of the system. These changes do
- not try to get at the underlying cause of the issues, but are instead behavioral in nature.
- These changes tend to be short-lived.
-
Second Order Change
- Changes that occur at a deeper level and fundamentally alter the
- system’s rules and organization. The system is reorganized in order to achieve a
- different, healthier level of functioning that can survive over time.
-
Nonsummativity
- The family system is treated as a whole and not just each individual
- family member.
-
Boundaries
- Abstract lines that exist between parts of the system and between the
- system and between different systems. They are typically defined by implicit and explicit
- rules.
- ○ Open System
- ○ Closed System
-
Open System
Refers to a system that allows for the continuous flow of information from outside the system.
-
Closed System
Systems that maintain boundaries that cannot easily be crossed; they are impenetrable.
-
General Systems - Treatment Goals
- ● Move the system towards an equilibrium.
- ● Assist the family in exploring and recognizing healthier interactions to decrease
- dysfunctional family behaviors or patterns.
- ● Help family challenge and rework their beliefs.
- ● Assist individual family members in seeing their role in any given dynamic.
- ● Increase each family member’s ability to understand the different experiences and
- perceptions of others in the family.
- ● Assist in correcting problematic or unhealthy feedback loops.
-
General Systems - Interventions
- ● Observe the feedback loops that occur within a family system.
- ● Explore the family’s:
- ○ Belief systems and family values
- ○ Rules and roles that are present in the family
- ○ The family hierarchy
- ○ Expectations
- ○ Circular causality between members of the family
- ● Reframe presenting issues as system issues rather than pathologizing one person’s
- symptoms.
- ● Explore each family member's role in dysfunctional interactions.
- ● Challenge the communication that occurs within the system.
-
Strategic - Theory of Change
Change occurs through action-oriented directives and paradoxical interventions.
-
Strategic - Role of the Therapist
- ● Therapist delivers directives that facilitate change, particularly around patterns of
- communication.
- ● Focuses on solving problem/eliminating symptoms
- ● Designs a specific approach for each person’s presenting problem
-
Strategic - Treatment Goals
- ● Solve the presenting problems
- ● Change dysfunctional patterns of interaction
-
Strategic - Interventions
- Paradoxical Directives
- Positioning
- Homework
- Prescribing the Symptom
- Restraining
- Ordeals
-
Paradoxical Directives
- Maneuvers that are in apparent contradiction to the goals of
- therapy, yet are actually designed to achieve them; paradoxical interventions help avoid
- confrontation with therapist’s instructions; undermines resistance by keeping clients in
- charge.
-
Positioning
- Therapist takes a more exaggerated and extreme view of the problem and
- the family is obligated to rebel. That leads to them seeing the ways in which they have
- competency.
-
Homework
- Assignments or directives that take place outside of therapy are essential to
- the therapy having a successful outcome. The underlying goal of the homework is to try
- to change the way the family dynamics function around the presenting problem that was
- identified in session.
-
Prescribing the Symptom
- A strategy in which the therapist encourages or instructs the
- client to engage in or practice the symptom.
-
Restraining
- The therapist will discourage change or changing too quickly in an effort to
- elicit the desire to change from the client.
-
Ordeals
- Particular type of symptom prescription in which clients are encouraged to
- carry out harmless but unpleasant tasks whenever symptoms occur; example: having to
- get up and clean the basement every time the client cannot sleep.
-
Strategic - Beginning Phase
- Define the problem; determine how the client understands the problem; assess
- family’s destructive patterns of relating and communicating the continued problem; state goals – what behaviors need to change and what would be the signs of change.
-
Strategic - Middle Phase
- Review attempted solutions; assign ordeals; prescribe the problem; relabel behavior;
- instruct client to respond to the problem in a new way.
-
Strategic - End Phase
- Plan for maintenance of new behavior; plan for future challenges; emphasize positive
- changes made.
-
Structural - Theory of Change
Change occurs through restructuring the family’s organization.
-
Structural - Therapist’s Role
- ● Therapist is active and involved.
- ● The therapist helps the family understand how family structure (relationships and
- hierarchies) can be changed, the impact of rituals and rules, and how new patterns of
- interaction can be integrated into the family.
-
Structural - Treatment Goals
- ● Restructure family system to allow for symptom relief and constructive problem solving.
- ● Change dysfunctional transactional patterns and create new ways of relating.
- ● Help create flexible boundaries.
-
Structural - Primary Concepts
- Alliances
- Coalitions
- Power Hierarchy
- Subsystems
- Family Map
- Disengaged Boundaries
- Enmeshed Boundaries
-
Alliances
Subgroups based on gender, generation, developmental tasks.
-
Coalitions
- Alignments where 2 or more family members join together to form a bond
- against another family member.
-
Power Hierarchy
- Leadership and direction must be provided by the adults, typically
- parents. Sometimes when parents are intimidated or insecure, the power is upside down
- and it leads to chaos.
-
Subsystems
- Families organize themselves by generation, relationship, and necessity.
- Examples: marital subsystem – spouses; parental subsystem: parents; executive
- subsystem: people who run the family; sibling subsystem – kids.
-
Family Map
- A tool the therapist will use to depict the relationship dynamics in the family
- including sub-systems, alliances, coalitions and boundaries. This tool is used to
- conceptualize the case outside of the actual therapy. It is not used or shared with the
- family.
-
Disengaged Boundaries
- Where family members are isolated from each other. Can lead
- to AOD use and is a result of rigid boundaries.
-
Enmeshed Boundaries
- Family members are overly dependent and too closely involved
- and reactive to other family members. Can lead to incest.
-
Structural - Interventions
- Joining
- Tracking
- Mimesis
- Unbalancing
- Reframe
- Enactment
- Boundary Making
-
Joining
- Therapist’s first task; involves blending in with the family, adapting the family’s
- affect, style, and language.
-
Tracking
- The therapist pays close attention to family members and how they relate to
- one another during an enactment or spontaneous behavioral sequence, noticing
- boundaries, coalitions, roles, rules, etc.
-
Mimesis
The therapist tracks the family’s style of communication and uses it.
-
Unbalancing
- Supporting someone who is in a one-down position, thus changing
- hierarchical position.
-
Reframe
- Putting the presenting problem in a perspective that is both different from what
- the family brings and more workable.
-
Enactment
- The actualization of transactional patterns under the control of the therapist.
- It allows the therapist to observe how family members mutually regulate their behaviors,
- and to determine the place of the problem behavior within the sequence of transactions.
-
Boundary Making
- Special case of enactment, in which the therapist defines areas of interaction that he rules open to certain members but closed to others. Example: a son is asked to leave his chair (in between his parents) and go to another chair on the opposite
- side of the room, so that he is not “caught in the middle”.
-
Structural - Beginning Phase
- Join with family; both accommodate to and challenge rules of family system;
- assessment/mapping of hierarchy, alignments, and boundaries; reframing of problem to include
- whole system.
-
Structural - Middle Phase
- Highlight and modify interactions; utilize enactments of issues to challenge participants
- and unbalance the system.
-
Structural - End Phase
Review progress made; reinforce structural change; provide tools for future.
-
Satir Communication - Theory of Change
- Change happens through self-awareness and improved communication. A humanistic
- approach.
-
Satir Communication - Role of the Therapist
- ● Active facilitator
- ● Resource detective
- ● Therapist is genuine and warm
- ● Honest and direct
-
Satir Communication - Treatment Goals
- The goal is for clients to increase congruent communication, improve self-esteem/confidence
- and personal growth.
-
Satir Communication - Key Concepts & Interventions
- Incongruent Communication
- Styles of Communication
- Placater
- Blamer
- Computer
- Distracter
- Leveler
- Modeling Communication
- Family Life Chronology
- Family Sculpting
- Take Responsibility
- Metaphors and Storytelling
- Transforming Rules
-
Incongruent Communication
Discrepancies between verbal and non-verbal cues.
-
Styles of Communication
- The rules that govern family interaction function as a method
- of ensuring the maintenance and preservation of the family’s current functioning level.
- Communication styles are:
- ○ Placater: Apologizing, never disagreeing, trying to please.
- ○ Blamer: Attacking others, fault finder, dictator, boss.
- ○ Computer: Super reasonable, intellectual, distant, always correct.
- ○ Distracter: Seeking approval by acting out, irrelevant.
- ○ Leveler: Congruent in their beliefs about self and others.
-
Modeling Communication
- Therapist uses “I” messages; expresses thoughts and
- feelings directly; avoids statements about what others are thinking or feeling; is honest.
-
Family Life Chronology
- Gathering history as far back as possible. Include: ideology,
- values, rules, disruptions, moves, and major events. What the family has been through
- and how those events impact the family. How past events and unresolved issues are
- carried out presently.
-
Family Sculpting
- Put people into a spatial metaphor – a physical representation of
- family members characterizations.
-
Take Responsibility
- Encouraging clients to take responsibility for how they felt, what
- they experienced, what meaning they made, what feelings they had about their feelings.
-
Metaphors and Storytelling
Used to help clients understand their roles.
-
Transforming Rules
Assisting clients to create more functional, less rigid guidelines.
-
Satir Communication - Beginning Phase
- Establish rapport, a sense of equality and hope. Assess communication patterns,
- stances, and concerns. Identify treatment focus and goals.
-
Satir Communication - Middle Phase
- Increase the family’s congruent communication. Support and strengthen each
- individual’s sense of uniqueness and self-esteem.
-
Satir Communication - End Phase
Help family practice, implement, and integrate changes and increase awareness of larger familial patterns.
|
|