-
Discuss the aeromedical implications of neurological disorders with respect to:
- • The impact of the condition on the operating environment
- • The impact of the aviation environment on the condition
- • Immediate fitness to fly
- • Outline what clinical information is required, including investigations and referrals, for determination of aeromedical disposition.
- • Describe the aeromedical implications of possible treatments for neurological disorders.
- • Discuss prognostic considerations that may impact on future fitness.
- • Propose a likely MECR process and aeromedical disposition for neurological disorders.
- • Apply an evidence-based aeromedical decision making framework to the aeromedical management of disorders affecting the nervous system.
-
• Traumatic Brain Injury
- • Subarachnoid Haemorrhage
- • Syncope
- • Headache
-
Summary
- Clinical Condition
- Likelihood of clinical event:
- •Incidence and prevalence data
- •Prognostic factors
- •Risk factors
- •Effectiveness of Rx
- Determined from:
- •Investigations
-
Management Consequences:
- •Muticrew only
- •As-or-with co-pilot
- •Type restrictions
- •Area restrictions
-
Traumatic Brain Injury
- • Relatively common
- • Higher incidence among young adults, often in association with alcohol excess
- • Many and varied classification schemes depending on any or all of the following:
- • GCS, Duration of LOC/PTA, Radiographic changes on structural brain imaging
- • NB. Inconsistent approach to classification within various ADF policy documents
-
Neurologists Guide to Grading TBI…..
-
Aeromedical Concerns
- • Will the condition impact on the aviation environment/operation (functional ability/incapacitating)?
- • Potentially yes
- • Primary aeromedical concerns following TBI are:
- • Post-Traumatic Epilepsy (PTE)
- • Neuropsychological impairment
- • Persisting neurological deficit
- • Will the aviation environment impact the condition?
- • Potentially yes.
- • Hypoxia, +Gz, mental and physical stress, circadian disruption, ?flicker/strobe effect
- Aeromedical Guide to Grading TBI…..
-
Criteria Mild Moderate Severe
-
Structural imaging
- CT/MRI Normal
- Non-displaced skull fracture
- MRI evidence of DAI
- or haemosiderin plugs
- Cerebral contusion
-
Subdural haematoma
Penetrating injury
-
LOC or PTA 0-30min >30min but <24hrs >24hrs
-
5yr risk PTE 0.5% 1.2 – 1.6% 10 – >20%
-
NB: Above grading specifically considers prognostic factors for PTE following TBI
-
Important Clinical Information
- • Detailed eyewitness account of nature of head injury and immediate sequelae is desirable
- • Mechanism of injury
- • Duration of LOC
- • Immediate vs delayed seizure activity
- • Ambulance and hospital records
- • Duration of PTA (be careful of confounding due to period of normal sleep and/or alcohol)
-
Investigations and Referrals
- • MRI or CT brain and skull
- • Neurological/Neurosurgical reports
- • Neuropsychological assessment
- • Sleep deprived EEG
-
Post-Traumatic Epilepsy
- • An “iron-driven” phenomenon
- • Any intra-cerebral haemorrhage or contusion is considered aeromedically significant
- • Immediate seizure within 24hrs of injury not predictive of future risk of PTE in isolation to other findings
- • Duration of PTA >24hrs as independent predictor
- • Risk of PTE >30% in severe TBI
- • Risk of PTE declines with time
- • 27% have occurred by 3/12; 56% by 12/12; 70% by 24/12
- • can remain elevated beyond background population risk levels for more than 5-7 years
-
Treatment Considerations
- • Will treatment of the condition impact on function in an aviation environment?
- • Use of prophylactic anticonvulsants not acceptable in civil or military aviation environments
- • Underlying risk of seizure for which Rx has been prescribed
- • Adverse effect of medication on cognition and alertness
- • Risk of withdrawal seizure upon abrupt discontinuation
-
Prognostic Considerations
- • All existing large prognostic studies for PTE are based on CT brain findings
- • Is use of modern high-resolution CT scanning and MRI leading to over-estimation of severity of TBI and PTE risk?
- • Significance of subtle impairment on neuropsychological assessment often difficult to interpret in the absence of reliable baseline data for comparison
- • An EEG will invariably be performed by Neurologist but realistically is of limited value due to high false-positive and false-negative rates
-
Military Aeromedical Disposition
- • Is TMUFF required?
- • Yes – minimum 1 month TMUFF following mild head injury
- • Permanent disqualification to be anticipated following severe head injury
- • Recruits vs. trained aircrew
- • Case by case determination for history of mild and moderate head injuries in applicants. Severe head injuries typically permanently disqualifying for all ADF entry.
- • Health Directives or other references
- • HD293 not to be applied for resumption of flying duties in injured aircrew
- • Likely UAMECR/IAMECR/CAMECR outcome
- • Case by case determination for moderate (6-24/12) and severe (2-5 yrs) head injury
-
• Case by case determination
- • Trained Navy Pilot
- • Fell from mountain bike wearing a helmet
- • striking head on tree stump
- • 1 min LOC, 25-35mins PTA
- • CT head normal
- • However, MRI head abnormal
- • 8mm haemorrhagic lesion
- • MRI head abnormal
- • 8mm haemhorragic lesion
- • No change on repeat MRI/MRA after 2months
- • Normal sleep deprived EEG
- • Neurologist states no reason “incidentaloma” should cause pilot to remain grounded (at 3mths)
- • Awaiting neuropsychological report
- • Classify as Mild or Moderate Head injury?
-
Subarachnoid Haemorrhage (Non-Traumatic)
- Condition Overview
- • Most commonly caused by rupture of cerebral aneurysms or arterio-venous malformation (AVM)
- • 15% of cases of acute SAH have no detectable source of bleed
- • Most common idiopathic source is perimesencephalic bleed (PM-SAH)
- Aeromedical Concerns
- • Will the condition impact on the aviation environment/operation (functional ability/incapacitating)? Yes
- • High mortality rate (50%)
- • High recurrence rate
- • 30% risk of re-bleed of aneurysmal SAH in first month and lifelong 2-3% annual risk
- • High chronic morbidity rate with neurological deficit and/or neuropsychological impairment
- • Increased risk of seizure following SAH
- • Vasospasm-induced ischaemic necrosis
- • Aneurysmal bleeding into neo-cortex
- • Iatrogenic risk following surgical intervention
- • NB: Much better outcomes with PM-SAH bleed
- • No increased mortality or morbidity
- • No increased risk of re-bleed
- • Will the aviation environment impact the condition?
- • ?Effect of physical and/or emotional stress increasing risk of re-bleed
-
Investigations and Referrals
- • CT/MRI imaging results
- • Source of bleed
- • MCA aneurysms are associated with higher incidence of subsequent seizure
- • Severity of bleed (Fisher Grade)
- • Better outcome for small bleeds detectable only on lumbar puncture (Fisher Grade 1)
- • Neurological/Neurosurgical opinion
- • Persisting neurological impairment
- • Neuropsychological testing
- • Risk factor management
- • Hypertension
-
Treatment Considerations
- • Will treatment of the condition impact on function in an aviation environment?
- • Surgical clipping and/or cotton-wrapping of aneurysms is associated with higher incidence of subsequent seizure disorder compared with endovascular coiling
- • Use of prophylactic anticonvulsants not acceptable in civil or military aviation environments
-
Military Aeromedical Disposition
- • PM-SAH may potentially be considered for return to flying duties
- • All other cases typically considered permanently disqualifying
- • Case by case determination
-
Syncope
- • Syncope is a symptom rather than a diagnosis
- • Transient, self-limited LOC
- • Pre-syncope symptoms of hypo-perfusion such as faintness of tunneling of vision but nil LOC
- • History of the event is paramount in establishing an accurate differential diagnosis
- • Cause remains unknown in one third or more cases (Framingham Heart study)
-
Condition Overview
- • Many and varied causes
- • Neurological
- • Cardiological
- • Gastrointestinal
- • ENT
- • Psychiatric
- • Physiological
- • Prolonged standing on parade
- • Dehydration
- • Heat syncope
- • G-LOC
- • Iatrogenic
- • Blood donation
- • Medication adverse effects
-
Aeromedical Concerns
- • Will the condition impact on the aviation environment/operation (functional ability/incapacitating)?
- • Will the aviation environment impact the condition?
- • Hypoxia
- • +Gz exposure
- • Physical and emotional stress
-
Important Clinical Information
- • Prodrome
- • Absent or present
- • Specific symptomatology
- • Posture at time of episode
- • Duration of episode
- • Activity immediately before episode and within 24hr period preceding episode
-
Important Clinical Information…
- • Head trauma
- • Post-ictal orientation
- • Urinary incontinence
- • Tongue-biting
- • Observer report
- • NB: Report of convulsive movements during episode is not diagnostic of seizure disorder
- • Bystander action
-
Important Clinical Information…
- • Frequency and pattern if recurrent episodes
- • Family history
- • Cardiovascular disease
- • Sudden death
- • Past medical history
-
Investigations and Referrals?
- • Necessary further opinion and investigation may include
- • Neurological
- • EEG and MRI
- • Cardiological
- • Resting and orthostatic BP
- • 12-lead ECG
- • Holter monitor
- • EST
- • Echocardiogram
- • Tilt-table testing
- • ENT
- • Vestibular function testing
-
Treatment Considerations
- • Will treatment of the condition impact on function in an aviation environment?
- • Treatment will depend on underlying cause
- • Any required treatment other than general advice to maintain fluid and electrolyte levels is to be considered disqualifying for military flying duties
-
Military Aeromedical Disposition
- • TMUFF duration will vary depending on aetiology
- • Recruits vs. trained aircrew
- • Infrequent episodes of simple vaso-vagal syncope (due to explained cause such as venesection, pain, etc) is not disqualifying
- • Recurrent unexplained syncope is disqualifying for all entry
- • Health Directives or other references
- • Mandatory 72hrs TMUFF following blood donation for aircrew (24hrs TMUFF for ATC/JBAC)
- • Likely UAMECR/IAMECR/CAMECR outcome
- • Single episode of simple vaso-vagal syncope from explained cause does not warrant MECR
- • Case-by-case determination depending on aetiology for all other cases
-
CASA Perspective
• All cases assessed individually
-
Follow-up Requirements
• Nil specific further review other than monitoring of frequency of subsequent episodes
-
Headache
- Condition Overview
- • Lifetime prevalence of headache approaches 100%
- • Diverse spectrum of headache disorder ranging from simple muscular tension headache to classical migraine
- • Individual may experience more than one headache type
- • Genetic predisposition for migraine headaches
- • Headache may not necessarily be the most prominent or aeromedically important feature of migraine
- • Vestibular or Ocular migraine without headache
-
Aeromedical Concerns
- • Will the condition impact on the aviation environment/operation (functional ability/incapacitating)?
- • Must consider the potential for sudden significant neurological symptoms such as loss of vision, photophobia, weakness, incoordination, and dysphasia
- • Nature of headache and associated symptoms are more important than formal headache diagnosis in determining aeromedical outcome
- • Will the aviation environment impact the condition?
- • Possible precipitation by altitude, glare, hot/cold extremes, dehydration, fatigue, circadian shift, and physical and/or emotional stress
-
Important Clinical Information
- • Precipitating factors
- • Is trigger identifiable and avoidable?
- • Speed of onset
- • Is there any warning aura?
- • Period of prodrome
- • Seconds…minutes…hours
- • Frequency of attack
- • Isolated or recurrent
- • Clusters
-
Important Clinical Information…
- • Neurological symptoms
- • Aura (?incapacitating in own right)
- • Photophobia
- • Visual changes
- • Paraesthesia
- • Paralysis
- • Vestibular disturbance
- • Dysphasia
-
Important Clinical Information…
- • Severity of headache
- • Analgesic requirements
- • Bedrest requirements
- • Lost time from work
- • Treatment requirements
- • Prophylaxis not acceptable for military aviation
-
Investigations and Referrals
- • Objective investigations most commonly find no abnormality
- • Neurological opinion
- • MRI brain +/-MRA
- • Detailed history is essential to Neurologist in diagnosis of headache type, but symptom reporting usually most accurate at first presentation with treating doctor…
-
Treatment Considerations
- • Requirement for headache prophylaxis disqualifying for military flying duties
- • Underlying medical condition is disqualifying
- • Adverse effects of some prophylactic medications (e.g. TCA, β-blockers) are disqualifying in own right
-
Prognostic Considerations
- • Period of observation required after first episode of severe headache
- • Permits Neurologist referral/investigation
- • Ascertain pattern of recurrence
- • Likely future disposition
- • Case by case determination
- • Nature and severity of headache and associated aura more important than diagnosis
- • More than 3 severe headaches per annum unlikely to be considered favourably
- • Avoidable trigger is beneficial
- • AVMED will consider need for restricted as-or-with aircrew duties
-
Military Aeromedical Disposition
- • TMUFF - Minimum 3 months after first episode severe headache
- • Recruits vs. trained aircrew
- • Single episode of migraine within last 3 years is disqualifying for recruits
- • Any history of recurrent migraine is disqualifying
- • Infrequent uncomplicated mild headache that responds to simple analgesia can be considered fit
- • Nil specific further review other than monitoring of frequency of subsequent episodes
-
Clinical Condition
- TMUFF?
- Likelihood of clinical event:
- •Incidence and prevalence data
- •Prognostic factors
- •Risk factors
- •Effectiveness of Rx
- Determined from:
- •Investigations
-
Manage Consequences:
- •Muticrew only
- •As-or-with co-pilot
- •Type restrictions
- •Referral Reports
|
|