-
What factors indicate an "equitable mortgage"?
- Existence of a debt/promise of payment by the deed's grantor
- grantee's promise to return land if debt is paid
- the amount advanced to the grantor/debtor was much lower than property value
- the degree of the grantor's financial distress
- the parties' prior negotiations
-
Under CL, how is a holdover tenant's rent established
- If notified prior to expiration of lease, the notified (new) amount and:
- commercial tenant: year-to-year
- residential: month-to-month
-
When can a tenant remove fixtures (residential and commercial)
- Residential: look to the nature of the fixture; the intent of the tenant; and damage caused by removal
- Commercial: Trade Fixtures Doctrine - can remove all commercial fixtures prior to removal
-
What are the Present Possessory Interests
- Fee simple absolute-absolute ownership with indefinite duration.
- Defeasible fees - Fee simple determinable/subject to a condition subsequent/subject to an executory limitation
-
What is a Fee simple absolute
- absolute ownership with indefinite duration.
- "To A and his heirs . . ."
- Characteristics: devisable, descendible, and alienable.
-
What are the three defeasible fees
- Fee simple determinable: terminates upon happening of stated event and automatically reverts to grantor
- Fee simple subject to a condition subsequent: can be terminated by grantor upon happening of a stated event.
- Fee simple subject to an executory limitation: terminates uponhappening of stated event, then passes to third party
-
Fee simple determinable
- terminates upon happening of stated event and automatically reverts to grantor.
- 1) "To A for so long as ... or during .. . or until ... "
- 2) Characteristics: devisable, descendible, and alienable.
- 3) Grantor retains a possibility of reverter.
-
Fee simple subject to condition subsequent
- Fee simple subject to condition subsequent-can be terminated bygrantor upon happening of a stated event.
- 1) "To A, upon condition that ... or provided that .. . or but if. . . or if it happens that . . ."
- 2) Characteristics: devisable, descendible, and alienable.
- 3) Grantor retains a right of entry or termination.
-
Fee simple subject to executory limitatio
- terminates upon happening of stated event, then passes to third party.
- 1) "To A, but if stated event happens, to B"
- 2) Characteristics: devisable, descendible, and alienable.
- 3) Termination is automatic and future interest in third party.Life estates-measured by the life of one or more persons.
-
Life estates
- Life estates-measured by the life of one or more persons.a. Life of grantee
- 1) "To A for life . .. "
- 2) Characteristics:
- - a) Creates reversion in grantor or remainder or executory interest in third party.
- - b) Life tenant entitled to ordinary uses but cannot commit waste
-
Waste in life estate
- Affirmative or voluntary waste-actual overt conduct that decreases value of estate.
- Permissive waste or neglect-failure to protect or preserve land.
- Ameliorative waste-change that economically benefits property.
-
Future interests - in grantor - possibility of reverter
follows fee simple determinable.
-
Future interests - in grantor - right of entry
power to terminate follows a fee simple subject to condition subsequent.
-
Future interests - in grantor - reversion
resulting interest when grantor transfers an estate lesser than grantor had
-
Future interests - in grantee - vested remainders
- Vested remainder - created in ascertained person and not subject to condition precedent
- Vested remainder subject to complete defeasance - remainderman's interest could be cut short by condition subsequent
- Vested remainder subject to open - remainder's interest subject to dimunition because additional, unascertained person(s) can qualify as class member
-
Future interests - in grantee - Contingent remainders
Created in unascertained person or subject to condiction precedent, or both
-
Future interests - in grantee - vested remainders - Merger Rule
Merger rule - destroy contingent remainder when one person acquires all present and future interests except contingent remainder
-
Future interests - in grantee - vested remainders - Rule in Shelley's Case
- Remainder to only grantee's heirs of a life estate in grantee not recogized
- Grantee takes in FS
-
Future interests - in grantee - vested remainders - Doctrine of Worthier Title
Remainder in grantor's heirs becomes reversion in grantor
-
Future interests - in grantee - two kinds of executory interests
- Shifting executory interest - 3rd person's interest cuts short an interest in another person
- Springing executory interest - 3rd person's interest cuts short an interest in the grantor or his heirs
-
Current estates - joint tenancy unities
- Time
- Title
- Interest
- Possession
- + clear expression of right of survivorship
-
Current estates - tenancy in common
- Each co-tenant owns individual part, with right to possess (use) the whole
- Interest is descendible, devisable, and transferable
- No right of survivorship
- Presumed co-tenancy
-
Current estates - tenancy by the entirety
- Marital estate that can be created only between married partners who share right of survivorship
- Special protections include:
- - creditors of one spouse cannot reach the tenancy
- - a unilateral conveyance by one is invalid
-
Current Estates - Rights and duties of co-tenants
- Possession - @ co-tenant has right to possess the whole, but no right to exclusive use
- Co-tenant may retain profits from own use of the property
- - must share net from 3rd party rent/exploitation of the land
- @ co-tenant responsible for fair share of taxes/mortgage
- Co-tenant repairs is entitled to contribution, so long as notice is provided
- Co-tenant making improvements has no right to contribution unless partition occurs
- Co-tenant cannot commit waste
-
Tenancy for years
- Leased for a fixed, determined period of time
- Written lease required
- ends automatically at termination date
- Notice is not required
-
Periodic Tenancy
- Lease that continues for successive periods until termination by proper notice by either partycreated by express agreement, implication, or operation of law
-
Tenancy at will
- Lease for no fixed period of duration and terminable at will of either landlord or tenant
- requires express agreement that lease can be terminated at any time
-
Tenancy at sufferance
- Hold over doctrine: T is permitted to live in a property after a lease term has expired, but before the landlord demands the tenant vacate the property
- Original lease conditions must be met, including the payment of any rents
- Otherwise, the tenant can be evicted at any time without notice
-
Landlord's remedies if T stops paying rent
- T breaches duty and is in possession, L can:
- - evict through courts
- - continue relationship
- - sue for rent due
- If T breaches duty and is not in possession, L can:
- - Treat T's abandonment as surrender
- - Ignore abandonment and hold T responsible for unpaid rent
- - Re-let on breaching T's behalf and sue T for deficiency
-
Landlord's duties and warranties
- Duty to deliver possession at beginning of term
- Implied covenant of quiet enjoyment
- Implied warranty of habitability
- Prohibition on retaliatory eviction
- tort liability for common areas, latent defects, assumed repairs, public use, or defects in a short-term lease of furnished dwelling
-
Implied covenant of quiet enjoyment
- Actual eviction: L excludes T from entire premises and T does not have to pay rent-
- Partial eviction: L excludes tenant from part of leased premises and T does not have to pay rent
- Constructive eviction- L's conduct causes premises to be uninhabitatble
- - T must vacate within a reasonable time after giving landlord notice and time to repair
- - T can lease and sue for damages
-
Implied warranty of habitability
- Standard: Residential premises ust be fit for human habitation
- T may vacate and terminate lease
- T may make reasonable repairs and deduct costs
- T may reduce or withhold rent
- T may remain in possession, pay rent, and seek damages
-
Effects of assignment of a lease
- Assignee stands in shoes of tenant in relationship with landlord (privity of estate)
- Assignee and landlord liable to each other for covenants that run with the land
- Assignor (original T) and L are no longer in privity of estate but remain in privity of contract.
- - L and assignor will be sexondarily liable to each other
-
Effects of sublease on lease
- Absent an express restriction in the lease, T transfers less than the entire leasehold interest
- Sublessee and landlord are not in privity of estate or contract
- Sublessor (original T) and L remain in privity.
- Sublessee pays rent to sublessor, and L may terminate main lease for nonpayment of rent.
-
Elements of Adverse Possession (COAH)
- Continuous: uninterrupted for statutory period
- Open and notorious: visible occupation of land to afford true owner notice and use as the owner would make
- Actual: actual physical entry onto premises
- Hostile: entry without owner's promission
- Tacking is permitted if there is privity
-
Definition - easement
Grant of nonpossessory interest that entitles holder to use or enjoyment of another's land
-
Definition - easement in gross
Holder acquires right to use servient tenement independent of possession of another tract of land
-
Creation of Easement by Prescription (COAH)
Continuous: uninterrupted for statutory periodOpen and notorious: visible occupation of land to afford true owner notice and use as the owner would makeActual: actual physical entry onto premisesHostile: entry without owner's promissionTacking is permitted if there is privity
-
Creation of easement by implication
- Easement implied from prior or existing use if
- apparent at time of division, and
- use is reasonably necessary to the dominant tenement's use and enjoyment
-
Creation of Easement of Necessity
- Landowner conveys portin of land, which is landlocked except over a part of grantor's remaining land
- Reasonable necessity for majority of states
- Strict necessity for minority of states
-
Creation of Easement by Grant
- Requires a deed of easement in writing and
- signed by holder of servient tenement
-
Termination of easement by estoppel
servient owner materially changes position in reasonable reliance on easement holder's assurances that easement will no longer be enforced.
-
Termination of easement by Necessity
- Easements by necessity end when necessity ends
- unless: created by express grant (i.e. in deed)
-
Termination of easement by destruction
- Destruction of servient land terminates easements on that land
- unless willful
-
Termination of easement by Condemnation
Condemnation of servient estate by eminent domain
-
Termination of easement by Release
Writing given by easement holder to servient holder
-
Termination of easement by Abandonment
Holder demonstrates by physical action an intent to permanently cease use
-
Termination of Easement by Merger
titles to easement and servient tenement vested in same person
-
Termination of easement by Prescription
Adverse, continuous interruption or use for prescription period
-
Definition of Covenant
- A written promise (a contractual limitation) to do or not do something related to land
- Types - affirmative or negative
-
Requirements for burden to run with the land (Covenant)
- Writing: original promise in writing
- Intent: original parties must have intended to bind successors
- Touch and Concern: covenant must relate to the use and enjoyment of the land
- Notice: actual, inquiry, or record notice
- Horizontal and Vertical Privity:
- -Horizontal: original covenanting parties were in a relationship independent of the covenant
- -Vertical: nonhostile connection between promisor and successor established by contract, blood relation, or devise
-
Requirements for benefit to run with the land (Covenant)
- Writing: original promise in writing
- Intent: original parties must have intended to bind successors
- Touch and Concern: covenant must relate to the use and enjoyment of the land
- Vertical Privity: nonhostile connection between promisor and successor established by contract, blood relation, or devise
-
Termination of Covenants & Remedy
- Written release
- Merger of benefited and burdened estates
- Condemnation of burdened property
- remedy: money damages
-
Definition of equitable servitude
A promise that equity will enforce against successor of burdened land who has notice
-
Requirements of Equitable Servitude creation
- Writing: original promise in writing
- Intent: original parties must have intended to bind successors
- Touch and Concern: covenant must relate to the use and enjoyment of the land
- Notice: actual, inquiry, or record notice
-
Implied equitable servitude/common scheme doctrine
- Original deeds contain common restriction but subsequent deeds are silent
- Reciprocal negative servitude: Subdivider had general scheme of residential development, including D's lot (via plat)
- - notice is required
-
Destroying equitable servitude - changed conditions
Standard: Conditions so pervasive that neighborhood character changes prevent enforcement of equitable servitude
-
Interest in Lateral Support
- Support of land in natural state: strict liability
- Support of land with buildings: strict liability if would have collapsed in natural state
- - otherwise negligence
-
Interest in Subadjacent Support
- Underground occupant must support surface and buildings existing on date subjacent estate was created
- Liability for subsequently erected buildings requires negligence
-
Definition and indications of Implicit/Reguatory Taking
- private claim that government regulation has effect of a taking:
- Categorical taking or all economic value
- Reasonable return test: no taking if owner left with reasonable ROI
- Diminution in value test: taking if no ROI
-
Definition of zoning
State power to reasonably control land use for health, safety, and welfare
-
Statute of Frauds elements
- Essential terms must be in writing:
- description of property,
- parties,
- price, and
- manner of payment
-
Partial performance of Statute of Frauds
- Part performance satisfied if buyer does 2 of 3 acts:
- takes physical possession
- pays all or substantial part of price
- and/or makes substantial improvements
-
Equitable Conversion - 2 main principles
- once contract signed, equity regards buyer as owner
- risk of loss placed on buyer
-
Definition of Marketable title
- Every contract for land contains implied covenant that seller will provide marketable title at closing
-
Possible defects to Marketable Title
- Encumbrances (ex. mortgages, liens, eaements, restrictive covenants) unless waivedDefects in record chain of title
- Adverse possession (title acquired by AP is unmarketable)
- Future interest held by unborn or unascertained person
- Existing violation of zoning ordinance
-
Theories for Seller's liabilities for defective property
- theories of: misrepresentation, active concealment, or failure to disclose
- Warranty of fitness or quality: non except sale of new home
-
Deed formalities
- Writing
- Signed by GrantorReasonably identifies partiesReasonably identifies land
-
Is acceptance of deed by grantee required?
Yes
-
Requirements for effective delivery of deed
- Formalities followed (writing, signed by grantor, described parties/land
- Grantor's intention to make deed presently effective
- - may be shown by manual delivery, notarized acknowledgement by grantor, recording, or other action showing intent
- Acceptance by grantee
-
Definition - quitclaim deed
A deed containing no covenants
-
Definition: General warranty deed
A deed that warrants against all defects
-
What 6 covenants are involved in every deed
- Seisin
- Right to convey
- against encumbrances
- quiet enjoyment
- warranty
- further assurances
-
Definition: covenant of seisin
Grantor has the estate he purports to convey
-
Definition: covenant of right to convey
Grantor has authority to make grant
-
Definition: covenant against encumbrances
Grantor warrants there are no servitudes or mortgages
-
Definition: covenant for quiet enjoyment
grantor promises grantee will not be disturbed by 3rd party
-
Definition: covenant of warranty
Grantor agrees to defend and to compensate grantee against claim of superior title
-
Definition: covenant for further assurances
Grantor agrees to act reasonably to perfect title
-
defintion: estoppel by deed
- subsequent acquisition of property by grantor inures to benefit grantee
- except against BFP
-
Definition: Bona Fide Purchaser
- Purchaser of property for value without notice
- Three kinds of notice:
- Actual
- Record/Constructive
- Inquiry notice
|
|