-
Nature vs. Nurture
philosophical debate about the relative importance of inborn characteristics vs. experience
-
Nativists
- - Kant
- - believed that innate or inborn mechanisms were the basis of knowledge and other important charateristics
-
Empiricists and Associationists
- Locke and Hume
- believed that sensory experience was the basis of knowledge and other important characteristics
- - 'tabula rasa' i.e. 'blank state'
- - learn by association, e.g. Law of temporal contiguity
-
Modern Day version of Nature vs. Nurture Argument: Genetics vs. Environment
False dichotomy: because for most psychological characteristics both genetic and environmental factor contribute
-
Currently there is considerable interest in studying genetic factors
- Genetic code: information for protein synthesis (amino acid sequence) contained in the sequence of nitrogen-containing bases in the structure of DNA
- DNA=>mRNA=>tRNA=>proteinsGenotype vs. Phenotype:
- - genotype: genetic makeup of organisms, encoded in DNA
- - phenotype: the expressed traits of an organism, is a product of genetic/environment interaction during every stage of development
- -Behavioral characteristics are PHENOTYPES, not genotypes
- -The genotypes associated with various behavioral phenotypes can either be located on a single gene locus or multiple gen loci (i.e. poly genetic)
- -The vast majority of behavioral traits appear to be influenced by polygenetic coding
- Twin Studies: look at
- - concordance (degree of agreement in characteristics between twins)
- - correlation (degree and direction of linear relation between variables)
-
Concordance studies with Schizophrenics
- Concordance - if one twin is schizophrenic, what is the probability that the other one is schizophrenic?
- Degree of identical twins reared apart:
- 15-40% depending upon the study
- Frequency of schizophrenia in general population: 1%
- There is a genetic predisposition towards schizophrenia
-
Correlation studies
- Correlation can be expressed by coefficient r
- r values can vary between -1.0 and +1.0
- Correlation coefficients capture how closely the relation between two variables follows a straight line
- - the sign of the correlation (+ or -) is related to the slope of the line
- - the absolute value is related to how closely the data resemble a line
- - if the r value is nearer to 0, it means no relation, while absolute value is nearer to 1.0 reflect a stronger linear relation
- - an r value of -1.0 or +1.0 reflect a perfect relation between the variables
-
Correlations Studies of IQ
- Most correlational studies with identical twins raised apart show IQ correlation about r=0.7
- The correlation squared (r^2) is equal to the proportion of variability in one set of IQs accounted for by variability in the other sets of IQs.
- r^2=0.7^2=0.49
- There is about 50% of the variability in IQ is accounted for by genetic factors
|
|