-
Corp Gov. Best practices (14)
75% of board independent
independent board chairman (not CEO)
qualified directors
election procedures
board self-assessment practices
frequency of separate sessions for independent directors
audit committee (only independent directors)
nominating committee (only independent directors)
compensation committee (link compensation to mostly performance)
use of independent and expert legal counsel
statement of governance policies
disclosure and transparency
insider or related-party transactions
responsiveness to shareholder proxy votes
-
Acquisition
one company buys a part of another company
-
Merger
one company absorbs another company entirely
-
Statutory merger
acquiring company obtains all of the target's assets and liabilities; the target company ceases to existr
-
Subsidiary merger
the target company becomes a subsidiary of the acquirer; often used when target has strong brand identity
-
Consolidation
acquirer and target cease to exist and new company formed
-
horizontal merger
two businesses operate in the same or similar industries two clothing stores
-
vertical merger
target company is along the supply chain of the acquring company: electronics retailer buying computer manufacturer
-
conglomerate merger
two companies form completely separate industries (shoe and food store)
-
Merger motivations (10)
synergies: economies of scale/scope
Achieving more rapid growth: increase rev growth, less risky to acquire growth
increased market power: market share and price influence, reduce dependence on outside suppliers
Gaining access to unique capabilities (cost effective way to acquire resources or capabilities)
diversification: finance theory: unlikely to increase value, stabilize cash flow
bootstrapping: positive impact on EPS from stock deal
Personal benefits for managers (higher comp, power, prestige)
tax benefits: acquirer can use target's tax losses to lower tax liability
unlocking hidden value: accomplished by improving management, adding resources, or improcing organizational structure
achieving international business goals: market inefficiences, avoid gov't policies (tariffs), use tech in new markets, product differentiation, provide support to existing clients
-
Bootstrapping EPS
Increased EPS that occurs when a high P/E firm acquires low P/E firm
increase in EPS
Real economic gains are not necessarily achieved
due to lower P/E
-
Pioneer/Development Phase (common mergers)
uncertain of product acceptance, lower profit margins and large capital requirements
Merger motivations: access to capital, management talent
types of mergers: conglomerate and horizontal
-
Rapid growth phase (common mergers)
High profit margins, accelerating sales, and earnings, low industry competition
motivations: access to capital, expand growth capacity
types: conglomerate and horizontal
-
Mature growth phase (common mergers)
reduced profit margins due to competition, but potential still exists
motivations, efficiency, economies of scale
types: horizontal and vertical
-
Stabilization phase (common mergers)
competition has reduced most of industry's growth potential
merger motivations: economics of scale, reduce costs, and improve management
types: horizontal
-
decline phase (common margins)
declining margins, overcapacity, and lower demand
merger motivations: survival, operating efficiencies, new growth opportunties
types: horizontal, vertical and conglomerate
-
Forms of acquisition (2)
stock purchase: target company's stockholders sell their shares directly to the acquiring firm
asset purchase: acquirer makes payment to target company to acquire assets
-
-
method of payments (2)
securities offering: target shareholders receive shares of acquirer's common stock
cash offering: target shareholders receive cash for shares
-
Friendly merger offers
acquirer approaches management
negotiations and due diligence
definitive merger agreemtn
public announcement
-
Hostile merger offers
acquirer submits proposal to board of directors
Unsuccessful proposal
tender offer: offer made to shareholders
proxy battle: proxy solicitation through votes
-
poison pill
shareholders given right to purchase more shares at a discount
flip-in pill: buy target's shares
flip-over pill: buy acquirer's shares
-
poison put
bondholders can demand immediate repayment in case of a takeover
-
staggered board
bidder can only win a minority of the board seats in one year
-
restricted voting rights
equity ownership aboce threshold level causes loss of voting rights unless approved by the board
-
supermajority voting provisons for mergers:
corporate charter requires shareholder support in excess of 50% (75%)
-
Fair price amendment
requires a "fair" price to be offered to shareholders based on independent appraisal
-
golden parachutes
managers receive lucrative cash payouts if they leave the target company after a merger
-
"Just say no" defense
refuse takeover offer, then convince shareholders to do the same
-
litigation
file a lawsuit against the acquirer to consume acquirer's time and money
-
Greenamail:
target repurchases shares from the acquirer at a premium: like a payoff to acqurer - think "blackmail", 50% tax on greenmail profits
-
share repurchase
target submits a tender offer for its own shares
-
leveraged recapitalization
target assumes a large amount of debt to repurchase shares
-
crown jewel defense
target sells a major asset to a neutral third party
risk is that court could declare sale illegal
-
pac-man defense
target makes a counteroffer to acquire the acquirer
-
white knight defense
friendly 3rd party to acquire firm
-
white squire defense
friednly 3rd party buys minority stake in target
-
-
-
Valuing a target company (3 methods)
1. discounted cash flow method
determine FCF and discount (like FCFF)
2. Comparable company analysis
use relative value metrics + premium
Start with minority interest values
3. comparable transaction analysis
same, only start with majority prices
-
Discounted Cash Flows Steps (6)
Which FCF modle to use (2 or 3 stage)?
Develop pro forma financials
calculate free cash flows
discount FCF's back to the present
Determine terminal value and discount to present (gordan growth model)
add discounted values for each stage
-
Comparable Company Analysis
Uses relative value metrics
adds a takeover premium to determine fair price to pay
big point: valuation relative to minoirty prices - does not use transacted firms
-
Comparable Company Analysis Steps
Identify set of comparables firms
calculate relative value measure based on comps market prices
calc descriptive stats and apply to the target firm
estimate a takeover premium
calculate the estimated take over prices (sum of stock value and premium)
-
Comparable Transaction Analysis Steps
Identify a set of recent takeover transactions
calculate various relative value measures based on deal prices
calculate descriptive statistics for the relative value metrics and apply those measures to the target firm
-
Post-merger value of an acquirer
Vat= Va + Vt + S - C
Vat = Post merger value of combined firm
Va= pre-merger value of acquirer
Vt = pre-merger value of target
S = synergies created by the merger
C = cash paid to target shareholders
-
Gains accrued to the target
Gaint = TP = Pt - Vt
Gaint = gains accrued to target
TP = takeover premium
Pt = price paid for target
Vt = pre-merger value of target
-
Gains accrued to the acquirer
GainA = S - TP
Adjustment for stock payment
Pt = (N x Pat)
n= number of new shares target recieves
Pat = price per share after merger annouced
-
Incremental Project Cash Flows (3)
- 1) initial investment outlay
- 2) after-tax operating cash flow over project's life (OCF)
- 3) terminal-year cash flow (TNOCF)
-
Outlay (Equ)
Outlay = FCInv + NWCInv
cost of fixed capital + change in non-cash current assets - change in non-debt current liabilities. Cash outflow if > 0
non-working capital inventory
-
after-tax operating cash flow
CF = (S-C-D)(1-T) +D
sales - cash operating expenses - depreciation expense , marginal tax rate
-
terminal year after-tax non-operating cash flows (TNOCF)
TNOCF = Salt + NWCInv - T(Salt-Bt)
Sal(t) = pre-tax cash proceeds from sale of fixed capital
NWSCInv = recovery of NWCInv
Bt = Book value of fixed capital
-
Adjustments if capital budgeting for replacement project
sale of old: reduce intial outlay by the after-tax proceeds from the sale (t=0)
depreciation: use only the difference between old and new depreciation
operating CFs: consider only incremental cash flows from new project
-
Always take higher NPV?
no, not if they have different life schedules. Use lease common multiple of lives method to equalize life of investment and select higher one
or use calculator to calc: equivalent annual annuity (EAA)
PV= -3245, N=6, I = 12 ->PMT = 789
higher EAA is better
-
Project Risk Analysis - 3 steps
1) sensitivity analysis - change single variable and see change in NPV
2) scenario analysis: uses best-case, worst case, and most likely case scnarios. Calc the mean and standard dev of NPV
3) monte carlo simulation: forecast probability dist. For key inputs, do random draw, calc npv, repeat
-
CAPM (equ)
Rproject = RF +ᵝproject [E(Rmkt) - RF]
-
Real options (5)
timing: wait for better info
abandonment: exit project early if failure
expansion: invest more $ if successful
Flexibility: pricing setting: change product price; Production flexibility: overtime, different materials, different variety of product
fundamental: entire project is an option; payoff depensds on underlying asset
-
Economic income
after tax operating cash flow minus economic depreciation
economic depcreciation is decline in investment's market value
-
Economic profit (equ def)
profit in excess of dollar cost of capital invested in project
EP NOPAT - $WACC
NOPAT = EBIT (1-tax rate)
$WACC = WACC x capital
market value added (MVA) is NPV based on economic profit
-
Residual income (alternative valuation models)
residual income = NI - equity charge
equity charge = required returin on equity x beginning book value of equity
-
Claims on valuation approach (alternative valuation models)
divideds CFs into the claims of deby and equity holders
Point: debt and equity cash flows valued separately, then added together to estimate value
CF to debt holders = interest and principal, discounted at cost of deby
CF to equity holders = dividends and share repurchases, discounted at cost of equity
-
Capital Structure objective: find optimal capital structure
determine mix of debt and equity that minimizes the firm's WACC (and maximizes stock price)
-
-
WACC = [wd x kd x (1-t)] + (we x ke)
-
Modigliani and Miller (MM) 3
Proposition 1: the value of a firm
Proposition 2: the WACC
know both with: no taxes and taxes
-
Concept 1
value of a firm is unaffected by its capital structure
V(L) = V(U)
levered and unlevered firm have same value
holds in perfect markets with no taxes, no transaction costs and no costs of financial distress
"size of pie is same, no matter how you slice it"
-
Concept 2
Proposition 2 no taxes
WACC unchanged by leverage
in a world with no taxes, capital structure doesn't matter
-
Concept 3
Prop 1 WITH taxes
debt shield increases the size of the pie
result: VL=Vu + (tax rate x value of debt)
PV of tax shield
Big point: optimal capital structure = 100% debt
-
Concept 4
as % of debt in capital structure increases, WACC decreases and firm value rises
-
Costs of Financial distress
costs incurred when company has trouble paying fixed financing costs (interest)
direct (lawyer expenses) and indirect (loss of trust)
Probability of financial distress: higher operating or financial leverage leads to higher probability of financial distress
better corporate governance lower probability
-
Agency costs of equity (3 types)
costs of conflict of interest between managers and owners
monitoring costs (better corp governance lower agency costs)
bonding costs (e.g. non-compete agreement)
residual losses (can't eliminate)
Point: greater financial leverage reduces agency costs, managers have less FCF to squander
-
Costs of Asymmetric Info
Managers know more about firm than owners
costs higher if complex products or poor financial statements
stock offering: negative signal (selling overvalued stock)
debt offering: positive signal (avoid selling undervalued stocK0
-
Pecking order theory
management sends signals based on their financing choices
financing choices are from most favored to least favored (pecking order) based on their info content
managers are lazy, choose easiest option if possible
internally generated funds (most favored)
debt
newly issued equity (lease favored)
-
Static trade-off theory def + pic
tax shield plus cost of financial distress
at some point: value added by tax-shield is exceed by value-reducing costs of financial distress
this point is the optimal capital structure
-
1) Establish the objectives
- input
- analyst's perpective
needs communicated by client or supervisor
institutional guidelines
- output
- purpose statement and specific questions to be answered
nature and content of final report
timetable and budge
-
2) Data collection
- input
- financial statements
communication with management, suppliers, customers, and competitors
- Output
- organized financial information
-
3) Processing data from step 2
output
adjusted financial statements
common-sized statements
ratios
forecasts
-
4) analyzing the data from step 2 and 3
results of analysis
-
5) develop and communicate conclusions
- input
- results from analysis using report guidelines
-
6) follow-up
- input
- periodically update information
- output
- update analysis and recommendations
-
ROE
ROE=NI/EBT x EBT/EBIT x EBIT/Revenue x Revenue/Avg Assets x Avg Assets/Avg Equity
- tax burden
- interest burden
- ebit margin
- asset turnover
- financial leverage
net margin
-
Earning Sources and ROE (things to analyze)
Assess firm's performance drivers by decomposing ROE using the extended DuPont equation
-
Asset Base (things to analyze)
examine composition of the balance sheet assets over time (common-size analysis, acqusiions and goodwill
-
Capital Structure (things to analyze)
capital structure must support the management's strategic objectives and allow the firm to honor future obligations (examine long-term debt-to-total capital
-
capital allocation decisions (things to analyze)
like marriott hotels. Consolidated statements hide different revenue drivers, disaggregate financial information into segments
-
Earnings quality (things to analyze)
persistenet and sustainable earnings are considered "high quality". Look at balance sheet approach, cash flow statement approach. Look at ratio of accruals to average net operating assets: intepretation, lower ratio, higher quality
-
Cash flow analysis (things to assess):
earnings confirmed with cash flow? Adjust operating cash flow by adding-back cash interest and cash taxes (if included). Compare to operating income
-
cash flow return on assets
Cash basis ratio
OCF / Avg total assets
-
Cash flow to reinvestments
Cash basis ratio
adjusted OCF/capital expenditures
-
cash flow interest coverage
Cash basis ratio
adjusted ocf/cash interest
-
market value decomposition (things to analyze)
determine the implied value of the parent excluding the value of associates
market capitalization of parent - parent's share of associates' market cap = implied value of parent
-
Off-balance sheet financing (things to analyze)
treat an operating lease as a finance (capital) lease
increase A/L by the PV of remaining lease payments. Remove rent expense from income statement and replace with depreciation expense and interest expense
RESULT: higher leverage and lower interest coverage
-
-
-
-
-
Compare temporal to current rate
1) LC appreciating or depreciating
2) examine numerator-translated at which rate (current, avg, etc.)-will numerator be larger or smaller?
3) examine denominator-same as numerator
4) Determine impact on ratio
-
Hyperinflation
when cumulative inflation rate over 3 years exceeds 3 yearscan't use current rate: lower asset and liability values-use temportal method
-
EBITDA (proxy for?)
Used as proxy for operating cash flow but ignores tax, interest, and working capital changes
-
Operating Income
Profits from operating activities EBIT
-
income from continuing operations
income after unusual or infrequent items and tax, but before extraordinary items and discontinued operations
-
Net income
income after all items below and above the line have been included
-
pro forma income
the firm's own measure of "operational earnings" - removes what management considers to be transitory items
-
lesson 2-5
Read the fine print, incomprehensible footnotes or MDA is warning sign
Be skeptical, earnings management is warning sign
Check for cash flow: NI/CFO should be equal to 1 over time
Undersatnd risks: business risk, interest risk, currency risk, collectability of AR, price risk of inputs, contingneices
-
lesson 6
- Using derivatives to hedge risk
- -Speculatively held derivatives: gains/losses to IS
- -cash flow hedge: manage CF volatility
- -Net investment in foreign operation hedges:
-
-
net investment hedge of foreign sub
Investment in foreign sub
equity with translation gains/losses
-
Manipulation Incentives of Earnings
Remuneration contracts: bonus and stock options
debt covenants: avoid technical defailts, interest costs tied to financial performance
Financing: subsequent issuing of debt or equity
-
Mean Reversion
earnings at extreme levels revert back to normal over time
-
Earnings Quality
Quality = persistence/sustainability
-
Aggregate Accruals (equ)
aggregate accruals = accrual based earnings - cash earnings
-
Net Operating Asssets (NOA)(Equ)
NOA = (Total assets - cash) - (total liabilities - total debt)
Balance Sheet Based Accruals
-
Aggregate accruals (equ)
Aggregate accruals = NOAt - NOA t-1
Balance Sheet Based Accruals
-
Accruals ratio (equ)
Accruals ratio = aggregate accruals / (NOAt - NOA t-1)/2
Balance Sheet Based Accruals
-
Aggregate accruals (Equ)
aggregate accruals = NI - (CFOt + CFIt)
cash flow accruals
-
Accruals ratio (equ)
Accruals ratio = aggregate accruals / (NOAt - NOA t-1)/2
Cash Flow Accruals
-
CFO
NI+Depreciation+LSD (liability you subtract if it decreases)
-
Dividends paid (equ)
Beginning RE + net income - Dividends paid = Ending RE
-
2 points on effectiveness of aggregate accruals
1) companies restating earnings had highest aggregate accruals
2) aggregate accruals = leading indicator of SEC enforcement actions
-
Revenue Recognition issues (3)
- 1) recognition of sale before completion of earnings process
- 2) recognition of sale without assurance of payment
Estimates: credit sales, deferred/unearned revenue, warranty provisions, sales returns
-
Lowering credit standards
lowering standards and selling to longer pay cycle consumers. Could be sign of accelerating revnue
-
warning signs: (8)
- bundled products
- management vested options
- pressure to meet earnings forecasts
- raising additional finance
- Large AR increase
- Large decrease in unearned revenue
- disproporationate revenue in last quarter
-
Recognizing revenue too early (4)
- 1) bill and hold sales
- 2) lessor use of sales type lease
- 3) recording sales prior to acceptance by customer
- 4) incorrectly using percent-of-completion method for long-term contracts
-
increase sales to cash collected from customers equ
'=sales/(revenue - change in AR + change in deferred revenue)
Ratio detection of revenue acceleration
-
days sales outstanding
365/AR TO or sales / Avg AR
Ratio detection of revenue acceleration
-
Expense recognition (3)
- 1) discretion over depreciation and amortization
- 2) impairment recognition
- 3) application of lower cost and fair value rules
-
3 signs of deferring expenses
- 1) increase in net non-current assets
- 2) consider asset growth in the context of expected sales and margin growth
- 3) software development costs (discretion) all show the capitalization of operating expenses
-
2 signs of misclassification of expenses as nonrecurring or non operating
- incorrect classification reduces COGS or SG&A
- 1) company has genuine spectial items that can be piggybacked
2) changes in operating profit margin or gross margin accompanied by spikes in special items
-
Big bath provisions (3)
- Make this bad REALLY bad, to improve future
- 1) impairments - future IS imrpovements via decrease in depreciation
- 2) restructuing or impariment changes reversed in subsequent periods
3) use of high or low bad debt reserves out of line with peers
-
Off-balance sheet liabilities (3)
- Assets and Liabilities avoiding recognition
- 1) operating leases
- 2) sale of AR with recourse
- 3) take or pay/through put agreemtns
- Equity accounted SPVs
Warning signs: firms following GAAP must report future cash flow obligations of operating leases - analyst should discount to PV and restate BS
-
CF statement issues: Classification issues: (3)
- 1) definition of cash and cash equivalents
- 2) marketable liquid investments may be CFI
- 3) solution: operatin gcash flows = CFO + CFI
-
CF Statement Issues: omitted investing and financing activities (2)
1) non-cash acquisitions-solution: utilize BS based measure of aggregate accruals
2) operating leases (solution: capitalize)
-
6 aspects of "Code of Ethics"
- 1) act in an ethical manner
- 2) integrity is paramount and clients always come first
- 3) use reasonable care; be independent
- 4) be a credit to the investment profession
- 5) uphold capital market rules and regulations
- 6) be competent, gain knowledge after CFA
-
7 Standards of Professional Conduct
- 1) Professionalism
- 2) Integrity of Capital Markets
- 3) Duties to Clients
- 4) Duties to Employers
- 5) Investment Analysis, recs, and actions
- 6) conflicts of interest
- 7) Responsibilities as a CFA member/candidate
-
Standard 1: Professionalism
A) knowledge of the law def and description
- A) Knowledge of the law:
- -understand all laws
- -comply with more strict law
- -do known knowingly assist in violation
- -notify supervisor or compliance
- -may confront wrongdoer directly
- -dissocociate if necessary
- -inaction may be participation
- Recommended
- -encourage firms to adopt code of ethics
- -report violations of other members
-
Standard 1: Professionalism
B) independenct and objectivity def and description
- B) independence and objectivity
- -maintain independence
- -do not offer, solicit, or accept any compensation that could compromise independence or objectivity
- -modest gifts okay
- -distinguish gifts from clients and gifts from entities trying to influence
- -disclose client gifts to employer, get permission if git is for future performance
- -Members responsible for hiring outside managers should not accept travel, gifts, or entertainment that could impair objectivity
- -i-banking relationship do now bow to pressure to issue favorable research
- recommended:
- -be careful with IPO share allocations
-
Standard 1: Professionalism
C) misrepresentation def and description
- C) Misrepresentation (lying)
- -don't misrepresent anything
- -don't guarantee a certain return
- recommended
- -quote sources, except for recognized financial and statistical reporting services
- -internal work can be used without source
-
Standard 1: Professionalism
D) misconduct: def and description
- misconduct
- -mommy rule: don't embarrass
-
Standard 2: Integriy of Capital Markets
A) material non public information
- -don't act on nonpublic information
- -"material" if disclosure of info would affect a security's price or if an investor wold want to know before making an investment decision
- -until released by press
- - Mosaic theory - no violation when an analyst combines non-material non-public information
- recommended:
- -chinese walls
- -review employee trades
-
Standard 2: Integriy of Capital Markets
B) Market manipulation
-don't distort prices or mislead market participants
-
Standard 3: Duties to Clients and Prospective Clients
A: Loyalty, Prudence, and Care
- Clients then Firm then Me
- "Client" may be investing public
- -vote proxies responsibly and disclose proxy voting to clients
- - "soft dollars" must benefit clients
- recommended:
- -disclose all possible conflicts
- -diversify
-
Standard 3: Duties to Clients and Prospective Clients
B:Fair Dealing
- -deal fairly with all clients, can't give IPO shares to bigger clients
- -fair does not mean equal
- -levels of service are okay as long as disclosed
- -all clients must have fair chance to act on every recommendation
-
Standard 3: Duties to Clients and Prospective Clients
C: Suitability
- -know client before recommendation or investment action
- -update IPS annually
-
Standard 3: Duties to Clients and Prospective Clients
D: Performance presentation
- -fair, accurate, and complete
- -can be brief presentation, not limited nature
- recommended:
- include terminated accounts as port of historical performance
-
Standard 3: Duties to Clients and Prospective Clients
E: Preservation of confidentiality
- Keep confidential unless:
- -illegal activities are suspected
- -disclosure is required by law
- -client or proespect allows disclosure
- -may provide confidential info to CFA institute for an investigation
-
Standard 4: Duties to Employers
A: Loyalty
- -act in best interest of employer until resignation is effective
- -all records are property of firm
- -don't solicit PRIOR to leaving
- -no whistleblowing for personal gain
-
Standard 4: Duties to Employers
B: Additional Compensation arrangements
-don't accept gifts that conflict interest of employer
-
Standard 5: Duties to Employers
c: responsibilities of supervisors
-make unreasonable efforts to detect and prevent violations of applicable laws
- recommended
- -have procedures for reporting violations
- -continually educate staff
-
Standard 5: Investment analysis, recommendations, and action
A: Diligence and reasonable basis
- -exercise diligence, independence, and thoroughness
- -ensure soundness of 2/3rd party research
- -consider scenarios outside of recent experience (CDO crash)
-
Standard 5: Investment analysis, recommendations, and action
B: Communication with clients and prospective clients
-disclose basic principles of investment processes
-distinguish between fact and opinion in presentation of investment analysis
- -maintain records
- -clearly communicate potential gains/losses
-
Standard 5: Investment analysis, recommendations, and action
C: Record retention
- maintain records to support research
- records are firm's property
- recommends retention of 7 years
when member changes firm, must recreate records from public sources and new firm's inforamtion (can't rely on memory or materials from old firm)
-
Standard 6: Conflicts of interest
A: disclosure of conflicts
-ensure disclosures are prominent and delivered in plain language
-disclose everything
-
Standard 6: Conflicts of interest
B: Priority of Transactions
- -clients transactions over member
- -don't use knowledge of impending trades for personal gain
-
Standard 6: Conflicts of interest
C: Referral fees
- disclose to everyone
- Disclose nature of consideration PRIOR to entering formal agreement for services
- update referrel compensation disclosure to employer quarterly
-
Standard 7: Responsibilities as CFA institute member
A: conduct
don't make CFA look bad
- don't cheat
- don't disclose tests
-
Standard 7: responsibilities as CFA
B: Reference to CFA
- don't misrepresent or exaggerate meaning
- complete PCS annually
- pay dues
okay to say "passed all levels on first attempt"
don't not us as noun (become a CFA)
-
soft dollar practices
use of brokerage by investment manager to obtain products/services to aid manager in investment making process
-
brokerage
compensation given to broker as payment for trade execution services
-
research
includes propietary (generated by broker) and third party (purchased)
-
mixed use reseach
research that can be used for both the investment management process and general management
-
agency trade
transaction that involves payment of a commission
-
principal trade
transaction that involves a discount or a spread
-
Soft dollar: investment manager duty (3)
- obtain best execution
- minimize transaction costs
- use client brokerage to benefit clients
-
Soft dollar rules (5)
1) disclose to client that manager may participate in soft dollar arrangements prior to doing so
2)consider trade execution capabilities
3) mixed use research: make reasonable allocation of cost based on expected usuage
4) no commitment of portion of brokerage to single broker
5) document aragements
-
3-level analysis to determine whether product/service is "research"
- 1) define product/service
- 2) determine usage
- 3) mixed us analysis - make allocation
if pass, done, or go to next
-
CFA Research objectivity standards:
1. Research objectivity policy
- Ffirm must have:
- -formal written independence and objectivity of research policy
- -supervisory procedures in place
- -senior officer to attest annually to compliance
-
CFA Research objectivity standards:
2. Public appearances
must disclose any personal and firm conflicts on interest
-
CFA Research objectivity standards:
3. Reasonable and adequate basis
- offer to provide supporting data
- disclose current market price of security
-
CFA Research objectivity standards:
4. i-banking
firms must separate research from i-banking operations
ensure that analysts do not report to i-banking
prevent i-banking from becoming involved with research/recs
-
CFA Research objectivity standards:
5: research analyst compensation
linke resaerch analyst compensation only to quality of research and recs
no link to corp finance or i-banking
-
CFA Research objectivity standards:
6.0 relationships with subject companies
Can't allow subject comapny to see any portion of report before release
-
CFA Research objectivity standards:
7: personal investments and trading
- firm's policies/procedures must:
- -address employee personal trading
- -no front-running client trades
- -ensure employees and immediate familty members not trade contrary to firm's recs (exception: severe financial hardship)
- -no IPO shares
-
CFA Research objectivity standards:
8: timeliness of research reports and recs
regularly issue reports on subject companies on a timely basis
-
CFA Research objectivity standards:
9: compliance and enforcement
enforce procedures
-
CFA Research objectivity standards:
10: disclosure
11: rating system
disclose conflicts of interests related to covered employees or the firm as a whole
Have rating system that investors find useful for investment decisions
-
covariance
an absolute measure of how closely variables move together
-
correlation
Standard measure of covariance between -1 and +1
only linear correlation (not parabolic)
-
-
correlation (r) equ
r1,2 = Cov1,2 / [σ1*σ2]
-
spurious correlation
linear relationship but no economic explanation (Super bowl wins and S&P 500)
-
t-test
- n - k - 1 degrees of freedom
- tbi = [estimate - hypothesized] / standard error
- Then test statistical significance:
- =estimate/standard error
-
dependent variable vs. independent variable
independent variable = explains the variation in the dependent variable (mortgage interest rates)
dependent variables: explained variable (housing starts)
-
Slope coefficient and intercept (equ)
- dependent variable: Y
- Intercept: b0
Slope coefficient: b1 Independent variable: Xi - Y1 = b0 + b1Xi
-
confidence intervals
point estimate +_ (reliability x variability)
-
Total variation in Y variable (equ)
- Total variation in Y variable (SST) =
- Variation explained by X variable (RSS)
- + Unexplained variation (SSE)
- k=# of independent variables
- = 1 for simple linear regression
n=sample size
-
Regression mean square (MSR)
Mean squared error (MSE)
equs
- MSR = RSS / k
- = RSS for simple linear regression
- MSE = SSE / (n-k-1)
- =SSE / n-2 for simple linear regression
-
-
3 limits of regression
- relationships change over time
- difficult to apply
- usefulness limited: all participants can observe relationships
-
P-values
p-value = smallest significance level (α) at which we can reject H0
-
assumptions of mulitple regression (6)
- 1) linear relationship between Y and X's
- 2) no exact linear relationship among X's
- 3) expected value of error term = 0
- 4) variace of error term is constant
- 5) errors not serially correlated
- 6) error term not normally distributed
-
f-statistic (def and equ)
tests whether any independent variable explains variation independent variable
F = MSR / MSE
with k and n-k-1 degrees of freedom
-
dummy variable
- binary variable
- always use one less dummy variable than states of the world
(e.g. four quarters? use three dummies)
-
Regression assumption -> condition if violated
1) error term has constant variance
2) error terms are not correlated with each other
3) no exact linear relationship among "X" variables
- 1) heteroskedasticity
- 2) serial correlation (autocorrelation)
- 3) multicollinearity
-
Durbin-Watson statistic
equ and 3 cases
- DW = 2(1-r)
- r=correlation of residuals from one observation to the next
- 3 cases:
- 1) no autocarrelation DW = 2
- 2) positive serial correlation: DW =0
- 3) negative serial correlation: DW = 4
-
Conditional Heteroskedasticity
def and test
t-stats are artificially high
standard error too low = t-stat too high = false significance
- Breusch-Pagan test:
- H0=no heteroskedacsticity
- Chi-square test: BP = Rresid2 x n (with k df)
-
correcting for heteroskedasticity
- Use robust standard errors
- called White-corrected standard errors
- -uses robust standard erros to recalc t-stats
- Result: standard errors higher, t-stats lower and more accurate
-
serial correlation def and detecting
Positive autocorrelation: each error term tends in same direction as previous term
t-stats are too high (same as heterosk)
detecting: scatter plot and Durbin-Watson statistic
-
correcting for serial correlation
- adjust the coefficient standard errors using the Hansen mthod and recalc t-stats
- =also corrects heterosked
-
multicollinearity def and detecting and correction
- two or more X variables are correlated with each other
- -Inflactes SEs, reduces t-stats
- -so variables falsely look unimportant
- no formal test
- tell-tale signs from regression data
- 1) significant f-stat overall, but insignificant t-stats
- 2) high correlation between x variables
correction: omit one ore more of the x variables
-
3 types of model misspecification
- 1) functional form:
- -important variables omitted
- -variables not transformed properly
- -data pooled improperly
- 2) correlation between error and X variables
- -x variable is lagged Y variable
- -forecast the past
- -measurement error
- 3) other time series problems
-
Logit models
calculate a probability based on logistic distribution
-
probit models
calculates a probability based on normal distribution
-
discriminant models
procude a score or ranking used to classify into categories (bankrupt, or not bankrupt)
-
log-linear trend model
assumes the dependent financial variable grows at some constant rate:
-
covariance stationary
- a time series must be covariance stationary:
- -constant and finite expected value
- -constant and finite variance
a nonstationary times series will produce meaningless regression results
-
autoregressive models
main idea and equ
the dependent variable is regressed against previous values of itself
xt =b0 +b1xt-1 + b2xt-2+...+εt
-
Mean reverting level (equ)
MRL = b0 / (1-b1)
-
cointegration
two time series are related to the same macro variables or follow the same trend
- -if cointegrated, go ahead use the model,
- if not, throw out the model
-
economic factors (4)
- Land, Capital goods, labor, entrepreneurial ability
- Grows when any of the above: grows or becomes more efficient
-
Preconditions for economic growth
Incentive system: most important factor
- Necessary social institutions
- § Markets: facilitates the exchange of info
- § Property rights: guarantees private ownership(more efficient markets)Monetary exchange: provides for efficient exchange of goods/services (more efficient markets)
-
Labor Productivity equ
Labor Productivity = real GDP per labor hour
-
3 sources of economic growth
- · Growth in physical capital
- · Tech change
- Human capital (education)
-
1/3rd rule
1/3rd rule: 1% increase in capital results in 1/3% growth, so rest is technological change
-
3 growth theories
- 1. Classical: (sad) in long run, we are all at the subsistence level (y-axis)
- 2. Neoclassical : (medium) Economic growth results for “lucky” discoveries of new tech. Growth is no long-term, but there is a permanently higher living standard. Real return = target return. If Real R is > target R, more competitions, returns fall back down and economic growth stops if no new tech comes.
- 3. New Growth Theory: (happy/American): economic growth gives incentives to create
- a. Real Return > target R = big profits
- b. Big profits attract entryDeclining returns motivate search for new tech
-
2 types of regulation
1) Economic: control pricint (think monopoly)
2) Social: social goals (safer drugs)
-
Negative side effects of regulation: (2)
1) Creative response: compliance with the letter of the law, but not the spirit
2) Feedback effect: change in consumers’ behavior in response to regulation
-
Regulator Behavior: (4)
- Theoretical: regulators are unbiased
- Pathological:
- 1) The capture hypothesis: regulators eventually controlled by industry
- 2) Share the gains, share the pains: regulators serve 3 people:
- a. Regulated Industry
- b. Public
- c. Law makers
-
Comparative Advantage
lowest opportunity cost to produce a product (instead of absolute advantage)
-
voluntary export restraints
agreements by exporting countries to limit the quantity of goods they will export toan importing country
-
nominal vs. real
- Nominal: price of one currency in terms of another
- Real: exchange rate adjusted for inflation differential between two currencies.
-
2 reasons for trade restrictions
- 1) gov'ts like tariff revenue
- 2) domestic producers affected by lower-cost imports use political means to gain protection from foreign competition
-
3 suport arguments for trade restrictions (3)
- 1) developing industries (protect)
- 2) anti-dumping: prohibit foreign producers for lowering prices
- 3) national defense: steel industry
-
3 factors that affect demand of FX demand:
- · Interest rates: high real rates should increase the demand for a currency for a country’s currency
- · Expected future exchange rates
Demand for impots/exports
-
Exchange rate policies:
Flexible
fixed
pegged
-
purchasing power parity
the same basket of goods should cost the same in different countries
-
inerest rate parity
currency appreciation/deprec over time should just offset differences in interest rates
-
3 factors affecting FX rates
1) interst rates: high real rates should increase the demand for a country's currency
- 2) expected future FX rates
- 3) demand for imports/exports
-
currency convetion: base and counter currency
Convention: “BASE CURRENCY:COUNTER CURRENCY” or USD:GBP = 0.554
.5440 Pounds / USD
-
Efficiency metric (% of ask)
Efficiency metric (% of ask) = ask – bid / ask = .1573%
-
The triangle (5)
- Process:
- · Start with fixed amount of Currency A
- · Convert to currency B
- · Convert to Currency C
- · Finally, convert back into Currency A
- IF you make money, you went the right way, if you lose: wrong way or no arbitrage
-
how do you know whether the bid or the as is the appropriate rate?
$/Euro
- $/Euros
- bid means turning Euro to dollar
- ask means turning dollar to euro
ask is always higher than the bid
-
(Bid-ask) spread is calculated just as for spot rates: (2)
- Typically, forward spreads > spot spreads
- Remember, spreads are measured as % of ASK
-
3 things afecting spot and/or forward rates
1) trading volume increases
2) currency volatility increases
3) term of the contract increases (just forward)
- 1) spread down
- 2) risk up, spread up
- 3) risk up, spread up
-
forward premium or discount equ
Forward premium/discount = [(forward rate - spot rate)/spot rate] * [360 / # of forward contract days]
-
Interest Rate Parity (IRP) equ + 2 points
IRP
Spot x [1+r countercurrency (n/360)] / [1+r basecurrency (n/360)] = Forward
if not equal, arbitrage exists
- Point 1: currency with higher nominal interest rate will depreciate
- Point 2: when IRP holds, an investor will make the same return holding either currency
-
Balance of Payment Accounts
Current Account + Capital Account + Official Reserve Account = 0
Current Account: net exchange of goods/services
Capital account: net flow of funds
Official Reserve account: funds held by gov’t in foreign currencies and loans to foreign governments
Running a current account is not a good measure of its economic health
-
3 Factors that Cause a currency fluctuation
- 1) Differences in income growth
- a. Rapit income growth = high demand for imports, so domestic currency depreciates
- 2) Differences in inflation rates
- a. High inflation = expensive exports
- b. Domestic currency depreciates
- 3) Differences in real interest rates
- a. Domestic currency depreciates
- b. High real rates attracts foreign investments
-
monetary expansion leads to
depreciation
-
Expansionary Fiscal policy (3)
- · Higher growth: increases imports; currency depreciates
- · Higher inflation: decreases exports; currency depreciates
- · Higher real interest rates: more demand for loans
- o Increases investment abroad; appreciation
-
absolute PPP
Relative PPP
absolute: same basket of goods will cost same everywhere
relative: changes in exchange rates will just offset changes in price levels
-
relative PPP equ
S0 [(1+Icountercurrency/(1 + Ibasecurrency)]t = E(St)
E(St) = expected future spot
-
international fisher relation
REAL interest rates should be the same across countries
Countries with high interest rates should have currency values that fall over time
-
uncovered interest rate parity equ
like covered interest rate parity
S0 x [1+rcountercurrency (n/360)]/[1+rbasecurrency(n/360)] = E(Sn)
|
|