-
How does Judee Burgoon explain what a theory is?
- A theory is a set of systematic, informed hunches about the way things operate. A theory is not just one inspired thought or idea.
- Theories always involve an element of speculation.
-
A set of hunches
- When we have hunches it means we don't have answers.
- If no puzzle to be solved or obvious explanation, then there is no need to develop a theory.
- A theory is not just one inspired thought or isolated idea.
- A develped theory offers some sort of explanation.
- A theory will give some indication of scope.
- Theory construction involes multiple hunches.
-
Theories as Lenses
- Like the lens of a camera it highlights the idea that theories shape our perceptions by focusing attention on some features of communication while ignoring other features.
- Negative--might regard what is seen through the glass as so dependent on the theoretical stance of the viewer that we abandon any attempt to discern what is real or true.
-
Theories as Maps
- Communication theories are maps of the way communication works.
- The truth they depict may have to do with objective behaviors (outside) or subjective meaning inside our heads.
- Negative--A static theory, like a still photograph, can nevery fully portray the richness of interaction between people that is constantly changing.
-
Theories as Nets
- Karl Popper says that theories are nets cast to catch what we call "the world" trying to make the mesh finer and finer"
- Theories are the tools of the trade.Small nets capture distinct types of communication in local situations.
- The world can be interpreted as everything that goes on under the sun-requiring a grand theory that applies to all communication.
- Conversely, catching the world cancall for numerous special theories--different kinds of small nets to capture distinct types of communication in local situation.
- Negative--the theories could be woven so tightly that they snag everything that humans think, say or do, also raising questions about our freedom to choose some actions and reject others.
-
Messages
- Messages are the very core of communication study
- Communication involves talking and listening, writing and reading, performing and witnessing or doing anything that involves "messages" in any medium or situation.
- Text is a synonym for a message that can be studied, regardless of the medium.
- Communication as a crossroads discipline because academic areas intersect with the study of communication.
- For a message to be considered communication it must elicit a response.
-
Creation of Messages
The content and form of a text are usually constructed, invented, planned, crafted, constituted, selected, or adopted by the communicator.
-
Interpretation of Messages
- "words don't mean mean things, people mean things.
- Humans act toward people or things on the basis of the meanings they assign to those people or things.
- Words and other symbols are polysemic, open to multiple interpretations.
-
Communication as a relational process
- Communication is a process of relating.
- Communication is a relational process not only because it takes place between two or more people bt also because it affects the nature of the connections among people.
-
Messages that elicit a response
- The final component of communication. If the message fails to stimulate any cognitive, emotional, or behavioral reaction, it seems pointless to refer to it as communication.
- "Falling on deaf ears"
-
Hunches as a system of concepts
- A theory lays out multiple ideas
- Specifies the relationship among them
- Links are clearly defined with a pattern emerging
- Ties together all of the ideas into a unified whol
-
Fred Camir's description of theory
- Theories are somethimes defined as educated guesses
- Not based on vague impressions nor accidental by-products of life
- Theories tend to result when the creator has discovered something in the environment which triggers the process of theory construction
-
Judee Burgoon' description of theory
A set of systematic, informed hunches about the way things operate. A theory is not just one inspired thought or idea.
-
|
|